The use of transitology in the field of transitional justice: a critique of the literature on the 'third wave' of democratisation

δείτε την πρωτότυπη σελίδα τεκμηρίου
στον ιστότοπο του αποθετηρίου του φορέα για περισσότερες πληροφορίες και για να δείτε όλα τα ψηφιακά αρχεία του τεκμηρίου*



The use of transitology in the field of transitional justice: a critique of the literature on the 'third wave' of democratisation (EN)

Grosescu, Raluca

This article analyses the role and the limits of transitology in framing transitional justice studies after the collapse of dictatorial regimes in Southern Europe, Latin America and Eastern Europe. It examines the evolution of the scholarship with reference to three main topics that have been pioneered by transitologists and developed further by transitional justice scholars, namely: the connections between justice for past abuses and democratisation; the determinants of transitional justice; and the relationship between accountability and the passage of time. The article argues that while transitology has nurtured important research initiatives in the field of transitional justice, its approaches suffer from serious shortcomings. They remained overly prescriptive and short-term in focus, and they often dehistoricised social phenomena. Adopting a teleological perspective on transitions supposedly bound for democracy, they overlooked comparisons and interconnections between transitional justice processes originating in democratic contexts and those arising from dictatorial settings. Moreover, in their attempt to build general typologies and establish causalities between types of dictatorial regimes, exit modes from authoritarianism and justice mechanisms, transitological approaches often failed to explain the peculiarities of national cases, and likewise paid scant attention to international contexts and transnational interactions. (EN)

info:eu-repo/semantics/article
info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Peer-reviewed Article (EN)

Eastern Europe (EN)
transitology (EN)
Southern Europe (EN)
transitional justice (EN)
democratisation (EN)
Latin America (EN)


Ιστορείν

Αγγλική γλώσσα

2015-12-03

https://ejournals.epublishing.ekt.gr/index.php/historein/article/view/2326

Cultural and Intellectual History Society (EN)


2241-2816
1108-3441
Historein; Τόμ. 15 Αρ. 1 (2015): Revisiting Democratic Transitions in Times of Crisis; 102-116 (EL)
Historein; Vol. 15 No. 1 (2015): Revisiting Democratic Transitions in Times of Crisis; 102-116 (EN)

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0
Copyright (c) 2015 Raluca Grosescu (EN)



*Η εύρυθμη και αδιάλειπτη λειτουργία των διαδικτυακών διευθύνσεων των συλλογών (ψηφιακό αρχείο, καρτέλα τεκμηρίου στο αποθετήριο) είναι αποκλειστική ευθύνη των αντίστοιχων Φορέων περιεχομένου.